Why Faking Your Own Kidnapping Is Always a Bad Idea

Why Faking Your Own Kidnapping Is Always a Bad Idea

At times new stories are published concerning people who concoct abductions of their own. There are never happy endings.

The latest victim to make abduction caper but fail has been 40-year old Sherri Papini from Redding, California, who has been sentenced to a year and half of prison. Papini was sentenced on September. 19 after she staged an elaborate ploy in the year 2016 to obtain Disability benefits.

Papini has pleaded guilty for making deceitful declarations to FBI agents regarding her disappearance, and to one charge of fraud by mail. Papini was missing from November 2016. Her husband then decided to release a request for her to return.

Then, three months later, a truck driver found her by the road’s edge 140 miles away from her last reported location. There were “various straps” to her body, which included the chain that was tied around her waist police said. Papini said two Hispanic females raped her by force, tied her up and beat her.

Papini retold the tale over the course of more than four years as law enforcement kept on investigating in hopes of identifying the people who kidnapped her. After a time they realized the truthabout it: It was a hoax. The goal of the woman was “to get rewards as a result of the alleged post-traumatic stress due to her abduction,” prosecutors said in the announcement of her latest sentence.

Alongside the sentence of 18 months and the 18-month sentence, The judge William B. Shubb ordered Papini’s to pay $309,902 compensation for the losses suffered through the California Victim Compensation Board, the Social Security Administration, the Shasta County Sheriff’s Office, as well as the FBI.

Public Costs

The story of Papini illustrates the danger of creating a false disappearance. While going on the run for a few days without informing anyone could seem insensitive, there’s nothing unlawful about it — even if you create a explanation. Legal issues arise when the disappearance results from an untruthful story that causes damage or unneeded public expense.

In the majority of states the act of the act of lying to police is known as “filing false reports,” that is typically an infraction of the misdemeanor. The typical penalties for conviction include up to one year in prison, as well as fines up to $1000.

Someone who submits an untrue report, knowing the report is most likely to result in harm or even death for anyone, nevertheless, is subject to far more severe penalties. Falsely filing a report in the hope of hurting the person is a crime and that means jail time and fines could be much more severe.

Additionally, as the case of Papini makes clear that the person who faked it could be held responsible for expenses inflicted by law enforcement as well as other organizations who wasted precious time and energy in search of non-existent criminals.

Self-Kidnappers’ Divergent Motives

A few of those who make up their own kidnappings make up stories and plots, often elaborate, to make money for themselves.

  • The 37-year old Florida woman with two children children, Quinn Gray, went missing in 2009, after she left her ransom request at the door to her family’s home worth $4 million situated in Ponte Vedra. The woman claimed that she had been kidnapped by men who demanded her husband be paid $50,000. In the end, Gray conceived the plan by collaborating with her lover who was a gasoline station employee. In the year 2011, Gray received a sentence to seven years’ probation. The judge that sentenced her ordered the payment of $33,000 in the St. Johns County Sheriff’s Office to cover the costs associated with the case.
  • In the year 2018, a 32-year-old California woman Maria Gonzales, claimed she was abducted and robbed in the hands of two criminals who force their way into her car with guns. Authorities were told she was carrying a huge amount of money that she planned to pay to subcontractors in her trucking business. The investigation revealed that she had fabricated the tale to escape from making payments totalling $9000. Police arrested her for an infraction of misdemeanor.
  • In 2020, the police of Chula Vista, California, were able to arrest a man aged 34 in the city of Chula Vista, California for falsely filing a kidnapping claim after spending long hours trying to rescue the man. They discovered that he’d orchestrated the kidnapping to try to steal cash from his family.
  • In January this year authorities in South Dakota charged a 22-year-old woman for attempted grand theft, and also with declaring a false claim of kidnapping. The woman fabricated the story in order to take money from her husband saying that kidnappers will murder her if he did not pay her.

Although many fake kidnappers focus on cash as the primary motive however, some fake kidnappers create their own fabricated stories to serve a purpose that is incredibly humorous:

No matter what your motives may be whatever, the message needs to be clear: faking the kidnapping of your own is not an ideal idea. If it’s because you were afraid to be at work or you were afraid of the parents of your friend or girlfriend You’ll now be carrying the record of a misdemeanor.

The police canget involved. They don’t want to waste their time searching for kidnappers that don’t exist.

There is no need to resolve this on your own – Seek the help of a lawyer

An appointment with a lawyer will aid you in understanding your options and the best way to defend your rights. Browse our lawyer directory for a lawyer in close proximity to your home who will be able to assist.